Tanisha Brahmer at the Pilger branch sitting at her desk helping a client.

10 Essential Questions to Ask When Shopping Around for a New Insurance Agency

Published October 10, 2024

Choosing an insurance agency is a significant decision that can impact your finances, peace of mind, and overall well-being. Whether you’re looking for auto, home, farm, or business insurance, it’s important to find a trustworthy and reliable provider who understands your needs and offers suitable coverage. But with so many agencies out there, how do you narrow down your options? The answer lies in asking the right questions. Here’s a guide to help you navigate the process of selecting an insurance agency by knowing what to ask.

1. What Types of Insurance Do You Specialize In?

Not all insurance agencies offer the same products, and some may excel in certain types of coverage over others. If you’re seeking specific policies, like commercial insurance for a business, or home insurance, it’s important to know if the agency has expertise in these areas.

Why ask this? An agency specializing in your needed coverage is more likely to provide tailored advice and better customer service, ensuring that your insurance policy fits your specific situation.

2. Are You an Independent or Captive Insurance Agency?

This question helps you understand whether the agency is bound to one insurance company (captive) or if they work with multiple providers (independent). An independent agency can shop around for policies from different insurers, potentially giving you more options and competitive pricing.

Why ask this? Independent agents can offer greater flexibility and a wider range of quotes. Captive agents may have in-depth knowledge of a particular company’s offerings but might not always present you with the most competitive options.

3. How Do You Determine My Insurance Needs?

Good agencies should not just offer cookie-cutter policies. They should perform a needs analysis that considers your personal circumstances, financial goals, and long-term needs. Ask how they assess your unique situation.

Why ask this? An agency that invests time in understanding your needs will be more likely to recommend appropriate coverage, saving you from being over- or under-insured.

4. What Are My Payment Options?

Insurance agencies often offer a variety of payment plans and options. You’ll want to know whether they offer monthly, quarterly, or annual payment choices and whether there are any additional fees for different payment methods.

Why ask this? Understanding your payment options helps you budget for insurance and avoid unexpected fees. Some plans may even offer discounts for paying upfront or setting up automatic payments.

5. Can You Explain the Claims Process?

No one likes to think about needing to file an insurance claim, but it’s crucial to understand how this process works before signing on. Ask how claims are handled, who to contact, and what the typical timeline looks like.

Why ask this? A smooth and transparent claims process can make a stressful situation much easier. An agency that guides you through this process and answers questions is essential when you need support.

6. What Discounts Am I Eligible For?

Insurance agencies often provide discounts based on factors like your driving record, home security system, or bundling policies. Ask about available discounts to ensure you’re getting the best deal possible.

Why ask this? Discounts can significantly reduce your premium, making insurance more affordable without sacrificing coverage. Knowing what you qualify for will help you make an informed decision.

7. How Do You Handle Policy Renewals and Changes?

Life is unpredictable, and your insurance needs can change. Ask how easy it is to update or modify your policies and what happens when it’s time to renew. Will they proactively review your policy and suggest changes based on your circumstances?

Why ask this? A good agency should offer flexibility and check in regularly to ensure your policy remains suitable as your life changes. This can save you from unpleasant surprises when it comes time to renew.

8. What Is Your Customer Service Like?

Customer service can make or break your experience with an insurance agency. Ask how accessible the agency is—can you reach them 24/7 in an emergency? What’s their typical response time? Do they offer support through various channels like phone, email, and online chat?

Why ask this? Insurance is a long-term relationship. You want to be sure the agency is easy to reach, responsive, and helpful, especially during times of need.

9. What Are the Policy Limits and Exclusions?

Always inquire about policy limits and exclusions. You’ll want to understand the maximum payout in the event of a claim and any circumstances that might prevent you from receiving a payout.

Why ask this? Knowing the limits of your coverage helps you plan for worst-case scenarios and prevents unpleasant surprises. It’s also essential for ensuring you’re adequately protected, especially if your home, car, or health is at stake.

10. Can You Provide References or Testimonials?

Ask the agency for references or testimonials from current clients. You can also search for online reviews or ratings to understand their reputation and track record.

Why ask this? A reputable insurance agency will be happy to provide references and will have positive reviews that can give you confidence in their service. An agency with glowing testimonials is more likely to provide the kind of customer care you’re seeking.

Final Thoughts: Don’t Be Afraid to Shop Around

Shopping for insurance is not a one-size-fits-all process, and you shouldn’t hesitate to ask these important questions. A reliable and reputable insurance agency like Midwest Bank Agency will gladly provide thorough answers, making you feel more informed and comfortable with your decision.

Remember that finding the right insurance agency can mean the difference between a smooth, hassle-free experience and a frustrating one. By asking these 10 questions, you’ll be well on your way to selecting an agency that has your best interests in mind and offers policies tailored to your needs.

Thank you for visiting Midwest Bank

The link you have selected is located on another server. Please click the "Go to URL" button to leave this website and proceed to the selected site.

Midwest Bank does not endorse this website, its sponsors, or any of the policies, activities, products, or services offered on this site or by any advertiser on the site.

Go to URL